The Problem With Both Harsh Parenting and Parenting That's Afraid to Upset a Child

Yesterday my 17-year-old was drinking a bottle of Sprite Zero that he’d bought himself. I’d also noticed last week that he had bought some cans of the same drink.

 

For some families, this may not be a big deal. But we don't generally have soft drinks at home and my children haven't grown up with them.

 

Now, my son is really health conscious. He cooks healthy, nutritious meals and snacks from scratch, goes to the gym four times a week and walks or plays basketball every day.

 

So I have very few concerns about his overall habits.

 

When he brought home the cans last week, I thought, he's having a treat. That's absolutely fine.

 

But when I saw the bottle this week, I thought... this could be becoming a habit, and I'm going to interrupt it.

 

I told him I didn't want soft drinks becoming something we regularly keep at home. He can choose to have one when he's out. I'm not interested in making certain foods or drinks "bad". I simply don't want something occasional to quietly become an everyday habit.

 

Ultimately, I want my children to notice how food, sleep, movement and other choices make their bodies feel.

 

I want them to be able to hear themselves.

 

And that includes their intuition.

 

But this tiny interaction got me thinking about something much bigger in parenting.

 

We seem to have created two extremes.

 

There is the harsher style of parenting many of us grew up with.

Because I said so.

You'll do what you're told.

Don't answer back.

The parent is in charge and the child is expected to comply.

 

Then, in trying not to repeat that, we can swing all the way to the other side.

We become so determined not to control our children that we become afraid to upset them.

 

I know this one personally.

 

I wanted my children to like me.

 

I didn't realise it at the time, but it was an extension of my own people pleasing. I was so accustomed to keeping other people happy that, at times, I did the same thing with my children.

 

I didn't always hold the boundaries I would hold today because their disappointment or anger was uncomfortable for me.

 

And that's an important distinction.

 

Sometimes what looks like parenting with empathy isn't actually about what our child needs. It's about our difficulty tolerating their unhappiness with us.

 

So we negotiate. We give in. We move a boundary we actually believe in because holding it means our child may be upset with us.

 

Over time I've had to learn that my children's disappointment doesn't mean I've done something wrong.

 

Because I don't think either extreme gives children what they really need.

 

Harsh parenting can teach a child..abandon yourself to stay connected to me.

Your feelings don't matter. Your opinion doesn't matter. Do what I say.

 

But parenting that is afraid to upset a child can teach something else..

Your discomfort is something I need to remove.

 

Neither prepares a child particularly well for life.

 

Sometimes someone will say no. Sometimes what we want isn't good for us. Sometimes we need to tolerate frustration, disappointment or desire without immediately acting on it.

 

And sometimes we need someone who loves us enough to hold a boundary even when we don't like it.

 

That doesn't mean dominating a child.

 

It means leading them.

 

My son didn't have to agree with my boundary (he didn't). He didn't have to be happy about it (he wasn't!).

 

I wasn't trying to shame him or force him to believe exactly what I believe.

 

But equally, I didn't need to abandon something I believe is important because he might not like hearing it.

 

I can hold a boundary and still leave room for him to be himself.

 

The goal isn't obedience.

 

But the goal isn't a child who is never upset with us either.

 

The goal is raising a human being who can remain connected to themselves while living within boundaries.

 

Who can disagree without losing themselves.

Who can tolerate discomfort.

Who can question us.

 

And who can eventually make thoughtful decisions without us standing beside them.

Because one day I won't be there to tell my son what to drink.

And I don't want to be.

 

I want him to have enough self-awareness to notice what makes his body feel good, enough critical thinking to question what he's being sold and enough self-trust to make his own decisions.

 

That is the long game of parenting.

 

We're not trying to control our children into making good choices forever.

 

We're helping them develop the internal compass that will eventually make us unnecessary.

 

That requires firmness without domination.

Empathy without abandoning boundaries.

Leadership without control.

 

It allows our children to learn...

I can be unhappy with a boundary and still be loved.

I can disagree with someone and still belong.

I don't have to abandon myself to stay connected to you.

 

And ultimately...

I can hear myself. I can trust myself. I can lead myself.

 

That's what I want for my children.

 

And it's at the heart of my Stressed to Best Parent Method... helping parents lead with enough calm and clarity to hold the boundaries their children need, without crushing the person they came here to be.

Next
Next

You don't need to be harder (or more strict)